Saturday, August 1, 2009

Paying for Health Care--Not a Zero Sum Problem

To understand the ramifications of any plan to finance health care, it would be helpful to explore the economic life cycle of most Americans. That cycle involves three phases. The first, an initial period of Dependency, begins at birth and lasts until the individual starts to earn a living. During that period he/she is a consumer, but not a producer.
The next period is Independancy. It is the period when he starts accumulating assets
and retirement benefits, from private and government retirement plans. It is also the period of high expenses for creating and raising a family with all the costs involved. During Independency he is both a producer and consumer.
The last period is again Dependency, supported by accumulated assets, retirement plans, and/or relatives. During this period he is still a consumer, but no longer a producer.
The purpose of health care is to improve the quality of life by reducing
Morbidity (illness and incapacity), and premature Mortality, and extending the life
span. A successful health care program will thus increase the length of
the final dependency period. It is in the final years of that period that the individual consumes the greatest amount of health care resources and incurs
the greatest expenses. Thus the dilemma.
There is another factor which is increasing the cost of health care to a large degree. Many of the more common ailments now have medications and treatments which
yield cures at modest costs. The more exotic and chronic ailments of age, such as Alzheimers, and degenerative conditions, do not respond to the most common medications. Much experimentation is ongoing for drugs for those conditions. Such
experimentation, and testing, is very costly. That cost must be amortized over a relatively small patient population, so the cost per patient is very high, and can continue over long periods, making those ailments very expensive to the health care
insurer, whichever type. That leads to proposals to limit treatment for such patients, a form of triage or euthanasia.
What plan we finally adopt will reveal a great deal about what kind of society we are, or pretend to be.

Sunday, July 12, 2009

Thunder on the Right

There has been a marked upsurge of bitter, threatening articles, talk show screeds,
and circulating Emails denouncing President Obama, and his policies at home and
abroad. They contain accusations of treason, conspiring with Muslims to undermine
this nation, betraying our ally Israel, deliberately bankrupting the nation, and replacing our Capitalist system with Socialism.
Some writers are advocating turning to guns to undo the election miscarriage which
brought us a black Muslim President. Such talk arouses the fringe nut cases like the
ones who murder physicians, museum guards, police officers and even presidents
with whom they differ, or against whom they have some imagined grievance.
From some investigation, it appears that many of the disgruntled writers and ranters are GOD fearing, white, pistol packing papas and mammas who voted for someone else
and can't recover from the loss. Many of them feel that their party, or cult, has
a GOD given mandate to govern this country and they intend to do so, by force if necessary. Persuasion is for sissy liberals (who are ashamed of our country anyway).
The bad economic times add to their stress, and could easily push them into rash
action. That would be the ultimate betrayal of our democratic ideals and values.
They would destroy the nation to "save" it. If there are any rational leaders of
this radical movement. now is the time for them to demonstrate some leadership
to calm the brewing storm.

Friday, July 10, 2009

HAVES vs HAVE NOTS--2nd Inning

The G8, then G17, meeting on what to do about global warming ended with a whimper.
The underdeveloped countries rightly blame the highly industrialized countries for the huge volume of accumulated CO2 that has fouled our atmosphere. Appealing to the have not nations to control CO2 emmisions means they would remain in a perpetual underdeveloped state. Development and industrialization require tremendous amounts of
energy, which are presently derived from coal and petroleum, both of which are major polluters, but relatively cheap to use. To expect the have not nations to forgo
industrialization is to keep them in perpetual poverty. They will never accept that, so it remains for the haves to take the lead, on two fronts.
First, they must be serious about finding alternative, renewable and clean sources of energy and incorporate them into energy efficient means of production.
Second, they must make those new energy sources and efficiencies available, cheaply, to the have nots, even if this results in their becoming competitors. Such competition would spur innovation and creativity, which in turn lead to better
products, cleanly made, at fair prices. All of those measures will reduce greenhouse
gases, in turn reducing global warming. Equally important, they would improve the standard of living and health all over the globe. That could reduce
terrorism and political conflict as the new haves acquire a stake in a peaceful, prosperous world.
This approach requires some altruism on the part of the haves, and an appreciation
of the new global interdependence which our communication and transportation technologies have brought about. It requires that our politicians think as world statesmen, not Repubs or Dems. Are they up to it, now that a statesman is President?

Wednesday, July 8, 2009

Convergence/Divergence

In the post WWII era the world was divided into two opposing blocs, the Western Alliance led by the U.S., and the Eastern/Asian Alliance led by the Soviet Union. The Cold War was characterized by numerous skirmishes on the bloc peripheries, such
as the Berlin Blockade/Airlift. The effective balance of military and nuclear power led the acceptance that armed conflict between the blocs was unthinkable. The
MAD doctrine (mutually assured destruction) kept an uneasy peace between the
principal antagonists. China was the main player outside the two blocs, with its
own expansionist goals and an increasing nuclear and missile capability. China's greatest concern was internal developement and industrialization. For that she needed
export markets, which exercised a restraining influence on her expansionist and
foreign adventures.
The present era confronts the two former great powers with new challenges from
rogue, radical countries that already have or will have nuclear weapons, awakening giants such as India and China, and rebellious client states on the periphery of
Russia.
In the Western hemisphere the U. S. sphere of influence is disintegrating. Nations such as Venezuela and Bolivia and others supporting them, are going their own way,
spurning U.S. policies. Their support in foreign affairs, and in the United Nations
can no longer be taken for granted.
In response to these new trends and power facts Russia and the U.S. are tentatively exploring a convergence of of interests. This could lead to new arms controls and reduction in nuclear armaments, more cooperation in international disputes such as with Iran,
the North Korean bellicosity and threats, and in Iraq, Pakistan, and Afghanistan.
President Obama's meeting this week with the Russian leaders has produced progress
on some of these issues and promises more to come. China appears ready to engage as well.
The President has some serious housekeeping to do in our own hemisphere, where divergence is the trend. He can't do it all alone. Now is the time for Hillary
to put on the steam!

Wednesday, July 1, 2009

Revolution requires Resolution

The people's revolt in Iran will likely not succeed in its immediate goal of
reversing the outcome of the fraudulant election. The suppresive power of the
reactionary state will wear down the protesters, because they lack dynamic leadership. Mousavi did not begin the protest to bring down the theocracy that
rules. He was protesting a fraudulent election which deprived him of the political power he sought for himself. The youthful population wanted change from a medieval, autocratic system which deprived them of opportunities to join the modern world and improve their material condition. Their only rallying point was that frail reed Mousavi. If he, or his more dynamic wife, had seized the reins of the protest and
accepted goals larger than his self interest, the revolt would have galvanized
the vast majority of Iranians to drive on to success. The bloody suppression by
the ruling council would have been self defeating by exposing their interest in control, not the general welfare of he nation.
The game is not over. The seeds of change, fertilized by the blood of martyrs such as Neda, have been planted. The vulnerabilities of the supreme Mullah and the Council
have been exposed. That will stimulate the opposition. They may change tactics,
but the trend has begun and will increase in momentum each day. Despite efforts to suppress communication among the dissidents, modern technology, combined with individual ingenuity, enables the revolutionaries to communicate and coordinate.
Time and evolution are on their side.
The role of the West is to keep the spotlight of public opinion on Iran, and to apply diplomatic and commercial pressure on the ruling clique. If it can be done in a manner which deprives the rulers from claiming that the revolution is foreign born, the West should provide clandestine assistance to the rebels.

Saturday, June 27, 2009

Health Care Insanity

A popular definition of insanity is "repeating the same actions and expecting a different result".
The private medical expense insurance industry has been around in one form or another for more than sixty years. The insurers trumpet the mantra that the industry
offers healthy competition in benefits and costs, so if it ain't broken, why fix it? Particularly if the evil, ineffective "government" would get involved in the fix.
The facts contradict the industry's hype. If the private system is so efficient, and benefits are provided to everyone, at reasonable cost, and the quality of the care
for which they will allow payment is so high, why have we had a health care crisis over more than 40 years? Why is congress spending so much time in every session
on the subject?
Under the surface many in congress are aware that a single payer system would be the
best solution. The powerful vested interests that are arrayed against such a solution control the votes of enough members to prevent such a plan from coming to a vote. So they will come up with a patchwork plan with just enough changes to give the appearance of progress but which will preserve the status quo, and the problems
and inequities within it.
Health care consumes such an enormous share of the nation's assets that recovery
from the current depression cannot occur unless its costs are reigned in. The status quo will mean deficits increasing annually, a drag on business recovery (to say nothing of expansion), and an increasing portion of the public without health care insurance. Don't we have a right to expect better from our Congress?

Tuesday, June 23, 2009

Health Care--Redux

The conservative pundits, George Will in the lead, are savaging Obama's proposal
for a gov't run alternative to private, for profit insurance plans that presently
cover an estimated 250 million persons. Their mantra is that such a plan, because it
would use the enormous bargaining power of the government, would price the private plans out of the market, limiting choice and diminishing the benefits of "healthy"
competition. If the private plans are so healthy, and competitive, why are we in a health care crisis?
The private health insurance industry consumes hundreds of billions of dollars annually, in which about 33% goes to overhead, profits and dividends. That 33% grows annually by inflation while producing no benefits to patients. In addition, because the insurers must control costs to assure profits, they impose costly and onerous
burdens on providers by pre-treatment approvals, limits on permitted procedures, and claims filing and paperwork. The practice of medicine has become an assembly line business with office managers, computer techs and automated claims and billing.
Medical care is NOT a commodity. Seeking it is not like purchasing an auto, or a Dunkin Donut. Illness and accidents are not optional, and treatment must be sought
without regard for ability to pay. Therefor society must provide it, but in the most efficient manner, recognizing that public resources come from the public.
If a single payor non profit plan were established, the premium dollars allready being payed, plus the savings of 33%, and cost reductions to providers, could easily cover the cost of insuring the 45-50 million currently uninsureds.
There would be some painful readjustments for the for-profit insurers, but we cannot
maintain a failed system just to avoid those.
It will take political courage by the President and Congress to effect such a change.
It is easier to accomplish now, when public pain is fresh, the failures of the status quo are so evident, and the private sector has no solutions to offer. Go for it Mr. President!